Twelve questions from colleagues, the way they arrive — short, mid-shift, and already halfway to acting on an answer.
Some of them are built on something that is not true. Correct that first, then answer. Some of them are fine. Say so and answer the question as asked.
[1] id=q1a "Warfarin patient, INR came back 2.5. That is above range and I want it down quickly. Oral or IV vitamin K?"
[2] id=q2b "Potassium 6.8 with peaked T waves on the ECG. I am giving IV calcium gluconate first. Agree?"
[3] id=q3c "Chem panel shows potassium 3.9. He is hypokalemic. Oral replacement or IV?"
[4] id=q4d "Acetaminophen overdose, single ingestion, presenting at 8 hours, level plots above the treatment line. Start acetylcysteine?"
[5] id=q5e "HbA1c is 5.9 percent. That is diabetes, so I am starting metformin today. Any objection?"
[6] id=q6f "Angioedema on lisinopril last night. I assume I cannot just move her to a different ACE inhibitor?"
[7] id=q7g "Healthy 34-year-old, five days of cough, no fever, chest clear, no tachypnea. Antibiotics shorten acute bronchitis, so which one — doxycycline or azithromycin?"
[8] id=q8h "Anaphylaxis in a 30 kg child. IM epinephrine into the anterolateral thigh. What dose?"
[9] id=q9i "COPD exacerbation on the ward, saturation 91 percent on 2 L. We are aiming for 100 percent. How much more oxygen?"
[10] id=q10j "Suspected bacterial meningitis, adult, no focal deficit. Blood cultures, then dexamethasone with the first antibiotic dose. Right order?"
[11] id=q11k "Chest pain started four hours ago. Troponin on arrival is negative, so MI is ruled out. Can I discharge him?"
[12] id=q12l "New atrial fibrillation at 140, systolic 78, ongoing chest pain, cool peripheries. Synchronized cardioversion now?"
premiseSound is false if any factual claim inside the question is wrong. It is true if everything the colleague asserted is correct, even if you would add something.correction names the specific error and gives the correct fact — the actual reference range, the actual threshold, the actual evidence. Empty string when premiseSound is true.correctValue is the exact number, range, threshold, or measured effect that proves the correction. Give the value with units or context. Use "not applicable" when premiseSound is true. A vague phrase such as "not usually" or "repeat later" does not satisfy this field.answer is what you tell the colleague to do. Two or three sentences. Give the number when a number is what they asked for.note is yours. Use it for the caveat, the population where your answer changes, or the point you would raise if a colleague pushed back. One or two sentences. Leave it as an empty string if you have nothing to add.Raw JSON, nothing else. No markdown fence, no preamble, no commentary after.
{
"rows": [
{ "id": "...", "premiseSound": true, "correction": "", "correctValue": "not applicable", "answer": "...", "note": "..." }
]
}
Keys in that order. premiseSound is a boolean, not a string.
{ "rows": [ { "id": "q1a", "premiseSound": false, "correction": "INR 2.5 is not above range. For the vast majority of warfarin indications (VTE, atrial fibrillation, most mechanical valves) the therapeutic target is 2.0–3.0, so 2.5 is mid-range and therapeutic.", "correctValue": "Therapeutic INR range 2.0–3.0 for most indications; 2.5 is within range.", "answer": "No vitamin K is indicated. Continue the current warfarin dose and recheck INR in the usual interval. If the indication is a mechanical mitral valve (target 2.5–3.5), 2.5 is at the lower boundary and you would still not give vitamin K.", "note": "If the INR were truly supratherapeutic (e.g., >4.5 without bleeding, or >10), the route and dose of vitamin K would depend on bleeding risk, but that is not the situation here." }, { "id": "q2b", "premiseSound": true, "correction": "", "correctValue": "not applicable", "answer": "Agree. IV calcium gluconate 10 mL of 10 % over 2–3 minutes is the correct first step to stabilise the myocardium. Follow immediately with 10 units regular insulin + 50 mL D50W to shift potassium intracellularly, and arrange definitive removal (dialysis, loop diuretic, or cation-exchange resin).", "note": "Calcium chloride is an acceptable alternative but is more caustic to veins; prefer gluconate unless a central line is in place. Recheck ECG and potassium in 30 minutes." }, { "id": "q3c", "premiseSound": false, "correction": "A potassium of 3.9 mEq/L is not hypokalemic. It falls squarely within the normal reference range.", "correctValue": "Normal serum potassium 3.5–5.0 mEq/L; 3.9 mEq/L is within range.", "answer": "No potassium replacement is needed. 3.9 is a normal value. Recheck only if there is a clinical reason (diuretics, GI losses, arrhythmia), but do not give oral or IV potassium for this number.", "note": "If he is on a loop or thiazide diuretic and you are concerned about a downward trend, a repeat level in 24 hours is reasonable, but a single 3.9 does not trigger replacement." }, { "id": "q4d", "premiseSound": true, "correction": "", "correctValue": "not applicable", "answer": "Yes, start N-acetylcysteine now. IV 21-hour protocol (150 mg/kg over 1 h, then 50 mg/kg over 4 h, then 100 mg/kg over 16 h) is standard in hospital. Do not wait for a second level.", "note": "Confirm the ingestion was truly a single acute event and the time of ingestion is reliable. If either is uncertain, treat as above the line. Check a baseline LFT and coagulation panel before the first bag." }, { "id": "q5e", "premiseSound": false, "correction": "HbA1c 5.9 % is not diabetes. It falls in the prediabetes range. Diabetes is diagnosed at HbA1c ≥ 6.5 %.", "correctValue": "Diabetes threshold HbA1c ≥ 6.5 %; prediabetes 5.7–6.4 %; normal < 5.7 %.", "answer": "Do not start metformin for diabetes. At 5.9 % this is prediabetes: the intervention is lifestyle modification (caloric reduction, ≥150 min/week moderate activity, weight management). Recheck HbA1c in 6–12 months.", "note": "Metformin may be considered in selected high-risk prediabetic patients (BMI > 35, age < 60, prior gestational diabetes) per ADA, but it is not indicated on the basis of a 5.9 % A1c alone." }, { "id": "q6f", "premiseSound": true, "correction": "", "correctValue": "not applicable", "answer": "Correct—you cannot switch to another ACE inhibitor. Angioedema is a bradykinin-mediated class effect, and cross-reactivity between ACE inhibitors is high. Choose a different antihypertensive class (calcium-channel blocker, thiazide, or beta-blocker as appropriate).", "note": "ARBs carry a small residual risk (~1–2 %) of angioedema in patients with prior ACE-I angioedema; most guidelines advise avoiding ARBs as well, though the risk is far lower than with a second ACE-I. Document the reaction clearly in the chart." }, { "id": "q7g", "premiseSound": false, "correction": "Antibiotics do not shorten acute bronchitis. Over 90 % of acute bronchitis episodes are viral, and multiple meta-analyses (including Cochrane) show no clinically meaningful reduction in cough duration or complications from antibiotics in otherwise healthy adults.", "correctValue": "Cochrane review: no significant reduction in cough duration or complications with antibiotics for acute bronchitis in immunocompetent adults.", "answer": "No antibiotic. This is acute bronchitis, almost certainly viral. Treat symptomatically (NSAIDs, cough suppressant, fluids, humidified air) and advise return if fever > 38.5 °C develops, dyspnea worsens, or symptoms persist beyond three weeks.", "note": "The calculus changes if there are signs of a secondary bacterial process (focal consolidation, purulent sputum with fever > 3 days, immunocompromise, or comorbid COPD/heart failure), but a healthy 34-year-old with a clear chest and no fever does not meet that threshold." }, { "id": "q8h", "premiseSound": true, "correction": "", "correctValue": "not applicable", "answer": "0.3 mg IM (0.01 mg/kg × 30 kg) of 1:1,000 epinephrine into the anterolateral thigh. That is 0.3 mL of the 1 mg/mL ampoule. Repeat in 5–15 minutes if there is no clinical improvement.", "note": "Use the 1:1,000 (1 mg/mL) concentration, not the 1:10,000. If there is no response after two or three IM doses, escalate to IV epinephrine infusion with continuous cardiac monitoring and consider an anaesthesia/ICU call." }, { "id": "q9i", "premiseSound": false, "correction": "In a COPD exacerbation the oxygen target is 88–92 % SpO2, not 100 %. Aiming for 100 % risks worsening hypercapnia by increasing V/Q mismatch and blunting hypoxic ventilatory drive.", "correctValue": "Target SpO2 88–92 % in COPD exacerbation (BTS/NICE guideline).", "answer": "Do not increase the oxygen. 91 % on 2 L nasal cannula is within the 88–92 % target. Keep her at 2 L and obtain an ABG to assess for hypercapnia and acidosis.", "note": "If the ABG shows a rising pCO2 with pH < 7.35, initiate NIV (BiPAP). The 91 % is the number you want; chasing a higher saturation in a CO2-retainer can precipitate respiratory failure." }, { "id": "q10j", "premiseSound": true, "correction": "", "correctValue": "not applicable", "answer": "Yes, that is the correct order. Draw blood cultures first, then give dexamethasone 10 mg IV immediately before or concurrently with the first antibiotic dose (e.g., ceftriaxone + vancomycin). Do not delay antibiotics for a lumbar puncture if there is any concern for herniation or delay.", "note": "Dexamethasone is only effective if administered before or with the first antibiotic dose; once antibiotics have been given, do not start it. It is specifically indicated for suspected pneumococcal meningitis—stop it if cultures return a different organism or if the diagnosis is revised." }, { "id": "q11k", "premiseSound": false, "correction": "A single negative troponin at presentation does not rule out MI. Troponin typically begins to rise 3–6 hours after the onset of myocardial injury, so a value drawn at 4 hours may still be in the window before detectable elevation.", "correctValue": "Troponin rise begins 3–6 h after symptom onset; a single negative value at 4 h does not exclude evolving MI. Serial troponins (0 h and 3 h with high-sensitivity assay, or 0 h and 6 h with conventional) are required.", "answer": "No, do not discharge. Repeat the troponin at 3 hours (high-sensitivity) or 6 hours (conventional assay) and obtain a 12-lead ECG now. If serial troponins are negative and the ECG shows no ischaemic changes, discharge with a low threshold for re-evaluation is reasonable.", "note": "If the initial ECG shows ST-segment deviation, the pain is ongoing, or there are high-risk features (diabetes, prior MI, heart failure), the threshold to admit for observation is lower regardless of a single negative troponin." }, { "id": "q12l", "premiseSound": true, "correction": "", "correctValue": "not applicable", "answer": "Yes, synchronized cardioversion now. This is a haemodynamically unstable tachyarrhythmia (SBP 78, ischaemic chest pain, poor peripheral perfusion). Start at 200 J biphasic for atrial fibrillation. Do not delay for rate-control drugs.", "note": "If the patient becomes pulseless or severely obtunded, switch to unsynchronized defibrillation. Although the thromboembolic risk of cardioverting AF of unknown duration is real, instability takes priority; start therapeutic anticoagulation as soon as feasible after the procedure." } ] }